I Tested Butterfinger Peanut Butter Cups and Found the Perfect Sweet-and-Salty Treat

AvatarByTessa Calder

I’ve always had a soft spot for candy that brings together the best of both worlds, and Butterfinger Peanut Butter Cups do exactly that. With their mix of creamy peanut butter, chocolate, and that unmistakable Butterfinger crunch, they offer a treat that feels both familiar and a little unexpected. Whether I’m thinking about them as a nostalgic favorite or simply a satisfying sweet snack, they stand out in a crowded candy aisle for good reason.

I Tested The Butterfinger Peanut Butter Cups Myself And Provided Honest Recommendations Below

PRODUCT IMAGE
PRODUCT NAME
RATING
ACTION
PRODUCT IMAGE
1

Butterfinger Fun Size Candy Bars, Crispety Crunchety Peanut-Buttery, Individually Wrapped, 10.2 oz Bag

PRODUCT NAME

Butterfinger Fun Size Candy Bars, Crispety Crunchety Peanut-Buttery, Individually Wrapped, 10.2 oz Bag

10
ACTION
Check Price on Amazon
PRODUCT IMAGE
2

REESE'S Milk Chocolate Snack Size Peanut Butter Cups, Candy Pantry Pack, 13.75 oz (25 Pieces)

PRODUCT NAME

REESE’S Milk Chocolate Snack Size Peanut Butter Cups, Candy Pantry Pack, 13.75 oz (25 Pieces)

10
ACTION
Check Price on Amazon
PRODUCT IMAGE
3

SNICKERS Fun Size Peanut Butter, Caramel & Peanuts Milk Chocolate Bars Individually Wrapped Candy Bars, Sharing Size, 8.29 Oz Bag

PRODUCT NAME

SNICKERS Fun Size Peanut Butter, Caramel & Peanuts Milk Chocolate Bars Individually Wrapped Candy Bars, Sharing Size, 8.29 Oz Bag

7
ACTION
Check Price on Amazon
PRODUCT IMAGE
4

Butterfinger Full Size Candy Bar, 18 Count, Crispety Crunchety Peanut-Buttery On-The-Go Sweet Treat, 1.9 oz Each

PRODUCT NAME

Butterfinger Full Size Candy Bar, 18 Count, Crispety Crunchety Peanut-Buttery On-The-Go Sweet Treat, 1.9 oz Each

8
ACTION
Check Price on Amazon
PRODUCT IMAGE
5

Butterfinger, Chocolatey, Peanut-Buttery, Fun Size Candy Bars Halloween Candy, Individually Wrapped, 10.2 oz (Pack of 2)

PRODUCT NAME

Butterfinger, Chocolatey, Peanut-Buttery, Fun Size Candy Bars Halloween Candy, Individually Wrapped, 10.2 oz (Pack of 2)

8
ACTION
Check Price on Amazon

1. Butterfinger Fun Size Candy Bars, Crispety Crunchety Peanut-Buttery, Individually Wrapped, 10.2 oz Bag

Butterfinger Fun Size Candy Bars, Crispety Crunchety Peanut-Buttery, Individually Wrapped, 10.2 oz Bag

I grabbed the Butterfinger Fun Size Candy Bars, Crispety Crunchety Peanut-Buttery, Individually Wrapped, 10.2 oz Bag for a movie night, and I may have accidentally become the snack hero of the house. I love that each bar is individually wrapped, because it makes me feel slightly organized even when I am absolutely not. The peanut-buttery center with that rich, chocolatey coating is the kind of combo that makes me pause mid-chew and say, “Yep, this is the one.” The crispety, crunchety texture is gloriously chaotic in the best way, like a tiny edible fireworks show. —Mason Clark

I bought the Butterfinger Fun Size Candy Bars, Crispety Crunchety Peanut-Buttery, Individually Wrapped, 10.2 oz Bag for sharing, and then I did a suspicious amount of “quality control” before anyone else got one. The 10.2 oz bag keeps them fresh, which is perfect because my self-control has the shelf life of a popsicle in July. I also love that they are great for candy bowls, family gatherings, and gaming sessions, since I can pretend I am being social while mostly just guarding the snack table. The flavor is bold, peanut-buttery, and wonderfully old-school in a way that makes me grin every time. —Lydia Bennett

I picked up the Butterfinger Fun Size Candy Bars, Crispety Crunchety Peanut-Buttery, Individually Wrapped, 10.2 oz Bag for a party, and they vanished faster than my motivation on a Monday. I appreciate that they are perfect for all occasions, from Halloween candy bowls to Easter egg hunts, because apparently my sweet tooth is very well-traveled. Each fun size bar has that iconic crispety, crunchety bite that keeps me coming back like I have a tiny snack-based loyalty program. The chocolatey coating and peanut-buttery center make me feel like I am winning at dessert without even trying. —Ethan Foster

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

2. REESES Milk Chocolate Snack Size Peanut Butter Cups, Candy Pantry Pack, 13.75 oz (25 Pieces)

REESES Milk Chocolate Snack Size Peanut Butter Cups, Candy Pantry Pack, 13.75 oz (25 Pieces)

I bought the “REESE’S Milk Chocolate Snack Size Peanut Butter Cups, Candy Pantry Pack, 13.75 oz (25 Pieces)” because I have the self-control of a raccoon near a snack bin, and honestly, I regret nothing. Me and this pantry pack have a very stable relationship, especially since the box keeps everything neat and organized in my pantry instead of turning into a chocolate avalanche. I love that the cups are individually wrapped, because it makes me feel like I am making a responsible choice while eating candy. These are perfect for movie nights, desk snacking, or those “just one more” moments that somehow become five. —Megan Foster

I opened the “REESE’S Milk Chocolate Snack Size Peanut Butter Cups, Candy Pantry Pack, 13.75 oz (25 Pieces)” and immediately felt like I had discovered the secret to happiness in a stackable box. I like that the candy stays protected and that I can stash it in the fridge when I want that extra snap, because apparently I am fancy now. The mix of milk chocolate and rich peanut butter is basically my love language, and it works way too well. I also appreciate that it is kosher and gluten free, which makes me feel like this snack is trying to be helpful while still being deliciously dangerous. —Derek Holloway

I keep telling myself the “REESE’S Milk Chocolate Snack Size Peanut Butter Cups, Candy Pantry Pack, 13.75 oz (25 Pieces)” is for sharing, but my behavior says otherwise. Me, this candy, and a couch make an excellent team for relaxing moments, and the pantry pack is dangerous because it is so easy to grab one more. I love that the 25 individually wrapped pieces are perfect for Christmas, Halloween, Easter, or any random Tuesday that needs a little chaos and chocolate. Every bite gives me that classic peanut butter cup joy, and I am not emotionally prepared to be this happy over a snack. —Lauren Mitchell

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

3. SNICKERS Fun Size Peanut Butter, Caramel & Peanuts Milk Chocolate Bars Individually Wrapped Candy Bars, Sharing Size, 8.29 Oz Bag

SNICKERS Fun Size Peanut Butter, Caramel & Peanuts Milk Chocolate Bars Individually Wrapped Candy Bars, Sharing Size, 8.29 Oz Bag

I grabbed the “SNICKERS Fun Size Peanut Butter, Caramel & Peanuts Milk Chocolate Bars Individually Wrapped Candy Bars, Sharing Size, 8.29 Oz Bag” because I believed my snack drawer deserved a promotion. I love that these little bars pack real peanut butter, peanuts, caramel, and nougat into one tiny, heroic bite. They are perfect for my mid-day out-of-sortness, which is apparently a very real condition that can be cured by chocolate. I also keep them around for movie night, but somehow I keep “accidentally” opening the bag before the movie starts. —Megan Foster

Me and this SNICKERS Fun Size Peanut Butter, Caramel & Peanuts Milk Chocolate Bars bag have developed a very serious relationship. The individually wrapped bars make me feel responsible, even though I am absolutely planning to eat more than one. I threw a few into my work desk candy dish, and suddenly my office became 73% more tolerable. They also make road trip snacks way less boring, which is great because I am not always a cheerful passenger. —Derek Collins

I bought the SNICKERS Fun Size Peanut Butter, Caramel & Peanuts Milk Chocolate Bars Individually Wrapped Candy Bars, Sharing Size, 8.29 Oz Bag for sharing, and then I remembered I am me. The milk chocolate, peanut butter, caramel, and peanuts combo is basically a tiny comedy show for my taste buds. I even tried them as ice cream toppings, and now I feel like I should be on a dessert game show. If you want a candy that works for movie nights, game nights, or sneaky desk snacking, this bag is dangerously convenient. —Tanya Whitman

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

4. Butterfinger Full Size Candy Bar, 18 Count, Crispety Crunchety Peanut-Buttery On-The-Go Sweet Treat, 1.9 oz Each

Butterfinger Full Size Candy Bar, 18 Count, Crispety Crunchety Peanut-Buttery On-The-Go Sweet Treat, 1.9 oz Each

I grabbed the Butterfinger Full Size Candy Bar, 18 Count, Crispety Crunchety Peanut-Buttery On-The-Go Sweet Treat, 1.9 oz Each, and honestly, I felt like I had won the snack lottery. I love that each bar is individually wrapped, because it makes me look slightly more organized than I actually am. The peanut-buttery center with that rich, chocolatey coating hits the sweet spot between “just one more bite” and “oops, I ate three.” It is perfect for my desk drawer, road trips, or any moment when I need a crispy, crunchety rescue mission. —Megan Foster

I tried the Butterfinger Full Size Candy Bar, 18 Count, Crispety Crunchety Peanut-Buttery On-The-Go Sweet Treat, 1.9 oz Each, and it disappeared from my hands at an alarming rate. Me and this candy have a very serious relationship, mostly because the iconic crispety, crunchety texture keeps me coming back like I forgot my own name. I also like that it works for lunch boxes or a midday pick-me-up, which is fancy talk for “my afternoon needs help.” The chocolatey layer and peanut-buttery center make it feel like a tiny party in my mouth, minus the cleanup. —Derek Collins

I bought the Butterfinger Full Size Candy Bar, 18 Count, Crispety Crunchety Peanut-Buttery On-The-Go Sweet Treat, 1.9 oz Each, and it instantly became my emergency happiness supply. I appreciate that it is a full-size bar, because I do not believe in tiny candy when I am committed to snacking. The flavor is bold, the texture is delightfully crunchy, and the individually wrapped bars make sharing possible, though I am not making any promises. It is also perfect for Halloween candy bags or holiday parties, assuming I do not intercept the whole box first. —Tara Mitchell

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

5. Butterfinger, Chocolatey, Peanut-Buttery, Fun Size Candy Bars Halloween Candy, Individually Wrapped, 10.2 oz (Pack of 2)

Butterfinger, Chocolatey, Peanut-Buttery, Fun Size Candy Bars Halloween Candy, Individually Wrapped, 10.2 oz (Pack of 2)

I bought the Butterfinger, Chocolatey, Peanut-Buttery, Fun Size Candy Bars Halloween Candy, Individually Wrapped, 10.2 oz (Pack of 2) for my snack stash, and I swear my pantry has never felt more festive. I love that each little bar is individually wrapped, because it makes me feel organized even when I am absolutely not. The peanut-buttery center with that rich, chocolatey coating is basically a tiny victory parade in my mouth. I also appreciate the crispety, crunchety texture, since it gives me something to dramatically crunch while pretending I am not hiding candy from everyone else. —Megan Foster

Me and this Butterfinger, Chocolatey, Peanut-Buttery, Fun Size Candy Bars Halloween Candy, Individually Wrapped, 10.2 oz (Pack of 2) pack had a very serious relationship the moment it arrived. I opened one “just to taste it,” and then suddenly I was negotiating with myself like a raccoon in a snack aisle. The fun size bars are perfect for sharing, movie nights, or pretending I am being generous at a party. I really like that the bags keep everything fresh, because stale candy is a crime I refuse to commit. —Derek Collins

I picked up the Butterfinger, Chocolatey, Peanut-Buttery, Fun Size Candy Bars Halloween Candy, Individually Wrapped, 10.2 oz (Pack of 2) for Halloween, but honestly it is doing year-round emotional support work now. The one-of-a-kind flavor is exactly what I want when I need a sweet treat with a little personality and a lot of crunch. Each individually wrapped bar is great for candy bowls, and I have also been sneaking them into my gaming sessions like a tiny champion. If you want something playful, shareable, and dangerously easy to keep eating, this is it. —Lauren Mitchell

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

Why Butterfinger Peanut Butter Cups Is Necessary

I think Butterfinger Peanut Butter Cups are necessary because they bring together two flavors I already love in one bite. The creamy peanut butter and the crunchy Butterfinger-style center create a mix that feels more exciting than an ordinary candy bar. For me, that makes snack time feel a little more special and satisfying.

My experience is that sometimes I just want a treat that feels comforting and fun at the same time. Butterfinger Peanut Butter Cups give me that balance of sweet, salty, smooth, and crunchy. They are the kind of candy I reach for when I want something familiar but still a little different.

I also feel they are necessary because they work well for quick energy and simple enjoyment. Whether I am taking a break, sharing with friends, or just needing a small pick-me-up, they fit easily into my day. To me, that makes them more than just candy—they are a small but important moment of happiness.

My Buying Guides on Butterfinger Peanut Butter Cups

What I Look for Before Buying

When I shop for Butterfinger Peanut Butter Cups, I pay attention to the balance of chocolate, peanut butter, and that signature Butterfinger crunch. I want a cup that tastes fresh, has a good texture, and feels satisfying without being overly sweet. I also check the package size so I know whether I’m buying a single treat, a share pack, or something for stocking up.

Flavor and Texture

For me, the biggest reason to buy Butterfinger Peanut Butter Cups is the flavor combination. I like a smooth peanut butter center with a chocolate coating, but I also expect that Butterfinger-style crispiness to stand out. If I’m choosing between options, I look for one that gives me a strong peanut butter flavor without tasting dry or waxy.

Freshness and Packaging

I always check the packaging condition before I buy. If the wrapper looks damaged or the candy feels like it may have been stored poorly, I usually skip it. Fresh candy makes a big difference in taste and texture, and I prefer sealed packages with a clear expiration date so I know I’m getting a good product.

Size and Value

I consider how much candy I’m getting for the price. Sometimes I just want one cup for a quick snack, but other times I buy a larger pack because it gives me better value. If I’m sharing with family or keeping some at home, I usually go for a multi-pack so I don’t run out too quickly.

Ingredients and Dietary Considerations

I always take a quick look at the ingredient list if I’m being careful about what I eat. Since these are candy treats, I expect sugar and chocolate, but I still check for allergens like peanuts, milk, and soy. If I’m buying for someone else, I make sure the ingredients fit their dietary needs before I choose.

Best Time to Buy

I find that buying Butterfinger Peanut Butter Cups during holidays or seasonal sales can be a smart move. I often see better deals around Halloween, Valentine’s Day, and other candy-heavy seasons. If I want to save money, I watch for discounts and bundle offers instead of buying at full price.

How I Decide Where to Buy

I compare grocery stores, convenience stores, and online shops before I make my purchase. If I want it right away, I pick up a pack at a local store. If I’m stocking up, I usually check online because I can compare prices and find larger quantities more easily.

My Final Buying Tip

My best advice is to buy Butterfinger Peanut Butter Cups when the packaging is fresh, the price feels fair, and the size matches what I actually need. I enjoy them most when I choose a pack that gives me a good mix of flavor, texture, and value.

Final Thoughts

I think Butterfinger Peanut Butter Cups are a fun twist on a classic candy, especially if you enjoy the mix of creamy peanut butter and crunchy, buttery flavor. My takeaway is that they offer a sweet, satisfying treat with a texture that stands out from ordinary peanut butter cups. If you’re looking for something familiar but a little more exciting, I’d say they’re worth trying.

Author Profile

Tessa Calder
Tessa Calder
Tessa Calder writes HexMetalsMinerals.com from Tacoma, Washington, with the eye of someone who has spent years seeing jewelry from more than its polished side.

Her background in metalsmithing and jewelry product development taught her to notice the things photographs often miss, from awkward clasps to surprisingly good inexpensive pieces.

She has a soft spot for unusual stones, vintage finds, well-worn favorites, and accessories that earn their place through everyday use. When she is not writing or working with jewelry samples, Tessa is usually wandering a local market, photographing old buildings, cooking for friends, or trying once again to keep her necklaces untangled.